A brief overview of what I learned from my data and how I will share my findings

After reviewing all my data, there are many patterns and themes that emerged so I will start with the main themes related to my research questions and then discuss the themes that are related as well as the context for some of the weaker data sources – hangout and google group chats.  Communication, collaboration, and interaction seem to be the major themes that emerge from data.  Communication includes how and what teachers and students communicate as well as how the communication evolves throughout the experience.  Collaboration is evident in how the teachers designed and supported the experience for their students but there is also a strong relationship between collaboration and interaction.  I will visually map out how the themes are subtopics are interconnected and I will use quotes or examples from the chat, interviews, my observations, and student wiki pages to demonstrate how the themes were evident in my data collection.

My post-it mapping of the chat history (from 186 pages)!
My post-it mapping of the chat history (from 186 pages)!

I used post-it notes to map on the wall so I could move and re-sort themes or group common patterns. The colors did represent interactions: blue – between and among students, purple – from teachers to students, pink – from students to teachers, and from that standpoint alone it was very interesting. I am sure students and teachers also interacted outside of the game but it’s an interesting look at the pattern within a virtual game!

As I read through the game chat, I began to gain familiarity with the players, the language and voice used, and interactions that students had with each other as well as with their teachers.  Interactions seem to expand beyond the assigned teams (and respective classes) and enable the collaboration to also increase between students.  An interesting thing that I observed and read in the chat, was that teachers were assessing student work in the game during the experience. The feedback was immediate and students were busy with other tasks while they waited to be assessed.

Teachers also began to encourage students to communicate primarily through the in-game chat (versus speaking to one another in the classroom); the open nature of these conversations meant that they could be monitored by teachers and other students could “listen in”.  Other students could (and did) also join your conversation or give suggestions relevant to the topics or issues being discussed.

The culture of the game evolved and communication, collaboration, and types of interactions were an important aspect of that culture.  Some important elements that were evident in the themes were:

  • Social communication, collaboration and interactions; some things that emerged included self-regulation or reporting of behavior, peer monitoring and interventions (there was some but not a lot of “tattling” to the teacher), and teachers played a very influential role in how students communication, collaborated and interacted with one another and with the teachers.
  • Language – a common language that emerged from the experience; words and phrases, greetings, routines, etc. that became commonly used in the game
  • Helping became a collective responsibility and expectation without seeming burdensome; students helped readily and easily in the game and later they all began to coordinate roles in helping the community.

Student wiki pages were all very similar (if there were completed by the time my data collection ended) and had a common format and purpose – to report what students had built.  I had expected to see more reflective journaling but because the students were highly active in the chat, it was a good way to examine the experience in their own words.

7 thoughts on “A brief overview of what I learned from my data and how I will share my findings

  1. I liked your sticky note wall. Were these color coded by theme or users? I like the mobile nature of the sticky notes. (Ex.I could put one piece of data under one theme, then move it if a better fitting theme emerges.) I think I will use them in the future when trying to establish themes.

    It was great that your teachers were able to get students to communicate primarily through the game as opposed to verbally talking. I am sure that this was awkward for the students at first.

    Overall, I am very impressed at your ability to sort through all of the data you collected. It takes a true talent to be able to sort through the data and pick out the important pieces that can inform your study. Way to go!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yes, that was definitely my strategy to be able to move and re-sort themes or group common patterns. The colors did represent interactions:
      blue – between and among students
      purple – from teachers to students
      pink – from students to teachers
      from that standpoint alone it was very interesting. I am sure students and teachers also interacted outside of the game but it’s an interesting look at the pattern within a virtual game!

      Like

  2. Great job finding some common themes, especially given the mounds of data you had to sort through. Looks like your themes aligned with the research and the purpose of this sort of technology tool. It is pretty inspiring to see how engaged the students were into this activity. I’m still trying to wrap my mind around this activity. You most likely have it written in your report already, but were students given an exact task to accomplish, or were they just given time to interact with and use this program?

    Like

  3. Once again, I am impressed with your work. The stick note idea is genius!
    At one point, I was concerned about the amount of information you were gathering; but you were able to take a large amount of data, and narrow it down to the relevant information for your research.

    Like

    1. Isn’t it great when we are able to get data that we didn’t expect as a result of a successful project? I found it interesting that you planned to get the meat of your student responses from the journals, but you received it from the chats instead. To me, that shows that they were highly engaged, which is evidence to support your research question of communication and collaboration, as well as engagement.

      Like

  4. I love your themes of collaboration, communication and interaction. Those are three things that you really want to see when students are using technology. It sounds like you have some great evidence/data to support the themes as well. I also love your sticky note wall. It’s a great visual to sort through the different types of interactions. I’m confused why hangout and and google group chat are weaker sources for you. Could you say more about that? Are you still planning on including that in your paper?

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yes, I will include them and discuss them in my analysis; they just weren’t used by teachers. The teachers rarely communicated with us throughout the experience (outside of the game) and when they did, it was mostly through email. Most of my interaction with teachers was actually in the game, through the game chat.

      Like

Any thoughts, feelings, opinions, suggestions?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s